Atypical Pilot Reviews

Atypical 1×01 – Antarctica

"But how can I make eye contact and look away? I mean, I'm not a mantis shrimp."


A coming of age comedy with a whole lot of heart, Atypical is a pleasant little surprise.

Tackling a lead with Autism is no easy task, but Keir Gilchrist is exceptional as Sam Gardner, an 18 year old boy on the autistic spectrum who is eager to finally start dating. His various idiosyncrasies and blunt remarks provide the show with a whole lot of humor, but it’s the anxiety and insecurities underneath that Gilchrist really taps into. As one character very poignantly says, “nobody is normal”, and I’m certain that any viewer watching Atypical can relate to Sam in some respect. He’s an outsider – a universal sentiment that everyone experiences for one reason or another. Fingers crossed that Gilchrist gets recognized at next year’s Emmy Awards because this is one brilliant turn.

The cast surrounding our star is also extremely likeable. I’m not Jennifer Jason Leigh’s biggest fan (she plays Sam’s mom and she was severely miscast in Revenge), but Sam’s sister Casey played by Brigette Lundy-Paine is terrific. She’s overprotective, loving, sarcastic and everything in between. I can already tell that her dynamic with Sam is going to be the show’s highlight. Amy Okuda provides a welcome dose of clarity and charm as Sam’s therapist Julia, while Michael Rapaport tackles a complex role (Sam’s somewhat distant but loving dad) with impressive nuance.

A heartwarming comedy with great performances and genuine heart. I’ve got high hopes for this one.

Nad Rating


  1. Finally started this! Only seen the first episode so far and I LOVED it! I can already tell the sister is going to be my absolute favorite.

    I didn’t like the mother either (at all, honestly) but I’m hoping she grows on me soon. Yeah, she was SEVERELY miscast on Revenge indeed.

    I also really appreciated just how funny this was. I feel like tackling autism with a dose of comedy is very smart and rare. The whole “twat” thing was hilarious. And I loved the red-head girl! A part of me wishes she sticks around, but I’m doubtful.

    Can’t wait to binge this all the way till the end! Will update you as I go along for sure! 😁😁

    1. Woohoo so glad you started. Trust me it gets
      better and better with every episode. You’re going to become addicted. Thank you Sara for the recommendation!

Share Your Thoughts

%d bloggers like this: